Thanksgiving Eve: The Biggest Bar Night of the Year and Pennsylvania’s Dram Shop Law

The night before Thanksgiving is one of the biggest bar nights of the year. But when bars and restaurants serve too much alcohol, a night of celebration can turn into a tragedy. And Pennsylvania law can hold them responsible.
Thanksgiving Eve, sometimes called “Blackout Wednesday” or “Drinksgiving,” has become a tradition for many people, especially college students and young adults returning home for the holiday. Friends reconnect, former classmates get together, and local bars and restaurants fill up with customers who don’t have to worry about getting up for work the next morning.
Unfortunately, the combination of crowded bars, excessive drinking, and people driving home late at night can be a recipe for disaster.
While most people understand that a drunk driver can be held legally responsible for causing an accident, many don’t realize that the bar or restaurant that served the alcohol may also be liable.
That’s where Pennsylvania’s Dram Shop Law comes into play.
What Is Pennsylvania’s Dram Shop Law?
Pennsylvania law prohibits licensed establishments, including bars and restaurants, from serving alcohol to minors or people who are visibly intoxicated.
When a bar violates that law and someone is injured as a result, the establishment can be held legally responsible for the injuries and damages.
This type of lawsuit is commonly called a Dram Shop case.
I actually wrote about Pennsylvania’s Dram Shop Law back in 2008 as part of my monthly Legal Lines column in The Kennett Paper. The law was important then, and it’s just as important today, especially around holidays like Thanksgiving when alcohol consumption increases.
The basic idea is straightforward. Bars and restaurants make money selling alcohol, but they also have a legal responsibility not to serve people who are already visibly intoxicated.
If they ignore that responsibility, the consequences can be devastating.
When Can a Bar Be Held Responsible?
Consider this example.
A customer spends several hours drinking at a bar on Thanksgiving Eve. By the end of the night, he’s slurring his words, staggering, and having trouble keeping his balance. Despite these obvious signs of intoxication, the bartender continues serving him drinks.
The customer eventually leaves, gets behind the wheel of his car, and causes a serious accident that injures or kills another driver.
Obviously, the drunk driver can be held responsible.
But under Pennsylvania law, the injured person or surviving family members may also have a claim against the bar that continued serving him after he became visibly intoxicated.
Dram Shop liability isn’t limited to drunk driving accidents. These claims can also arise when an intoxicated patron assaults someone in a bar fight, injures a pedestrian, or suffers injuries himself after being improperly served.
The important point is that the bar’s violation of the law must have caused or contributed to the injuries.
Proving That Someone Was Visibly Intoxicated
One of the biggest challenges in a Dram Shop case is proving that the customer was visibly intoxicated when the alcohol was served.
It’s not enough to show that someone had a high blood alcohol level after an accident. Pennsylvania law generally requires evidence that the person exhibited visible signs of intoxication at the time of service.
Those signs might include slurred speech, bloodshot or glassy eyes, stumbling, staggering, unusually loud or obnoxious behavior, or difficulty maintaining balance.
Witnesses who were at the bar can be important. So can surveillance footage, receipts, and testimony from bartenders and other customers.
In some cases, expert witnesses can use information about alcohol consumption and blood alcohol levels to help explain the person’s likely condition at the time of service.
But proving visible intoxication is only part of the case.
The injured person must also establish that the improper service of alcohol was a factual cause of the accident and resulting injuries.
For example, if a customer was overserved at a bar but then consumed substantial additional alcohol somewhere else before causing an accident hours later, establishing that causal connection may become more difficult.
Why These Cases Matter
Serious drunk driving accidents can leave victims with permanent disabilities, enormous medical bills, lost income, and lifelong pain and suffering.
Sometimes they result in death, leaving families devastated emotionally and financially.
The drunk driver may have limited automobile liability insurance and insufficient personal assets to compensate the victims for their losses.
When a bar or restaurant has violated Pennsylvania’s liquor laws, a Dram Shop claim may provide an additional source of compensation.
It also serves another important purpose: encouraging bars and restaurants to train their employees, recognize signs of intoxication, and stop serving customers who have had too much to drink.
Enjoy Thanksgiving Eve, But Be Responsible
There’s nothing wrong with getting together with friends and enjoying a few drinks the night before Thanksgiving.
But customers need to make responsible decisions about drinking and driving, and bars and restaurants need to take their legal obligations seriously.
If a bartender sees someone who is obviously intoxicated, continuing to serve that person isn’t just a bad decision. It can create legal liability if someone gets hurt.
As a Pennsylvania personal injury lawyer with more than 30 years of experience, I’ve seen how a single act of negligence can change lives forever.
So enjoy Thanksgiving Eve. Catch up with old friends. Have a great Thanksgiving.
Just remember that the responsibility for preventing drunk driving tragedies doesn’t rest solely with the person behind the wheel.
Sometimes, it also rests with the person behind the bar.
About the Author

Tim Rayne is a Pennsylvania personal injury attorney with MacElree Harvey. With more than 30 years of experience, Tim represents people injured in car accidents, drunk driving accidents, and other serious injury cases throughout Chester County and Southeastern Pennsylvania.
Tim has offices in West Chester and Kennett Square and also meets with clients virtually. He can be reached at 610-840-0124 or trayne@macelree.com or you can check out his website www.TimRayneLaw.com.
TimRayneLaw.com

Leave a Reply